University of Minnesota Libraries

Evaluating the Credibility of
World Wide Web Pages

Assignment for
QuickStart Module 5: Finding World Wide Web Pages
QuickStart Module 7: Evaluating Sources

Directions: Using the START evaluation criteria in the left hand boxes, evaluate each Web page you plan on using in your paper. In the boxes on the right, explain how the Web page you chose meets each particular criterion. Make photocopies of this worksheet for each Web site you evaluate.
Note: Do not include Web pages you found through the Library's databases (from LUMINA at http://www.lib.umn.edu). Include only those pages you find on the "free" Web.

Web Page Address (URL): __________________________________________

Scope
  • Is your topic covered fully?
  • How does the site compare with other information you've seen on the topic (journal articles, books?)
  • What aspect of the topic doesn't the Web site cover?
 
Treatment
  • What is the site's purpose: To inform, persuade, present opinions, report research or sell a product?
  • Does the Web site contain documented facts or personal opinion?
  • Does it show any bias?
  • Do the graphics add to the content of the site?
  • Are sources for information cited?
 
Authority
  • Is the author or source of information identified?
  • Are the author's qualifications, experience and/or institutional affiliation given?
  • Is the author's education and/or experience related to the topic?
  • Is contact information for the author included in the document?
  • What type of institution (government, university, company, or non-profit) supports this Web site? What more can you discover about the organization, using the Web or other sources?
 
Relevance
  • Can you use this information to support an argument you make in your paper or project?
  • Has the information on the page been transcribed from another source? (If yes, this indicates second-hand information; you might want to check the original source.)
  • Did you get to this Web site via a link from a Web site you know and trust?
 
Timeliness
  • Is the content up to date?
  • Is the date of creation or most recent revision clearly shown?
  • Regardless of the date, is the information still useful?
 

Quickstudy: Library Research Guide


Books and More | Articles and More | Research Guides | Reference Sources | Ordering Materials | Borrowing Services | Ask Us! | Hours | Help | Home
©2008 by the Regents of the University of Minnesota -- Twin Cities. University Libraries. All rights reserved.
LUMINA® and MNCAT® are registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
Appropriate Use of Computer Workstations and Electronic Resources and Privacy Statement
If you have any comments about this web site or page, please let us know!
Last revised: November 29, 2000
URL: http:///research/instruction/lessons/a_eval_web.phtml
The University of Minnesota is an equal opportunity educator and employer.